With help from Southern Souffle, Local Milk, Food52, and Blogging Over Thyme.
This recipe was a little much for our little household of two — it’s is more suited for four or even six — but everything is easily scaled down. I’ve made a half-batch of the biscuits and I’ve also frozen the extras, both with good results. Gravy will keep up to a week in the fridge, but I have not tried freezing it, so it may be best to make smaller batches as needed.
I tried out a few variations on this biscuit recipe, all with good results. The one above is ultimately closest to Beth’s gorgeous rendition. Substituting cake flour makes for a lighter, more tender biscuit, but I don’t think it’s truly necessary. For the “buttermilk,” you can use 2/3 cup regular, unflavored yogurt and 1/3 cup milk if you don’t have Greek yogurt on hand, or if you happen to have buttermilk, simply use 1 cup buttermilk. I just don’t usually have buttermilk, so a yogurt and milk combination has always been my go-to.
For a really revelatory, life-changing biscuit, you can up the butter content to 3/4 stick (6 tbsp) as per Erika’s recipe or even 1 stick (though in that case, decrease the “buttermilk” to 3/4 cup). For a biscuit I’d be serving with a very rich gravy anyhow, I thought it was fine conserving the butter for another use, so I kept it at 1/2 stick — but boy, that double-butter batch blew my mind, it was so good.
Also, you’re much better off consulting the biscuit goddesses linked above for tips on how to make your perfect fluffy, lofty, sky-high biscuits, but just a few observations from my my end — I really, really like grating frozen butter to make biscuits (as per Laura’s method) in the same way that I do for pie crust, but you can cut the butter in too. Also, you can use a rolling pin to roll the biscuit dough out if you like, but I thought patting with my fingers as per Erika’s method worked just as well and gave me a tad more control. Be super, super gentle in handling the dough at all times, and they’ll do just fine, even the scraps.
Finally, don’t be shy with the black pepper in the gravy! It’s hard to over-pepper a gravy — black pepper makes it shine.